How to Choose an Auction House in Minneapolis: What to Ask
The right auction house for you is the one that puts its fees in writing, can show you who bids on its sales, and tells you exactly when and how you'll be paid. Ask those questions of every house you talk to, including ours, and the answers will sort them out quickly.
At the end of this guide we explain how the process works at our gallery in Edina so you can compare us on the same terms.
What should you ask about fees?
Ask for the full fee schedule in writing before you sign anything. A seller's commission is the obvious cost, but it isn't the only one. Some houses charge separately for photography, cataloguing, insurance, storage, or a "buy in" fee when a lot fails to sell. Others fold everything into one rate.
Neither approach is wrong. What matters is that you can read the agreement and know what you'll net on a $500 sale and a $5,000 sale. If the house won't hand you a written schedule, or the agreement runs to many pages of fine print, treat that as an answer in itself.
Who will actually be bidding on your items?
An auction is only as good as the people watching it. Ask how the house reaches bidders: is it a room sale with a local crowd, an online only sale, or both? Which platforms does it list on? How many registered bidders does a typical sale draw, and from where?
The reason this matters is simple. A George Morrison painting or a Georg Jensen flatware set will find its strongest buyers among collectors who may live nowhere near Minnesota. A house with a national or international bidder base can put your lot in front of them. A house selling mainly to a local crowd may still do well with furniture and everyday household goods, but not with specialist material.
How will your items be photographed and catalogued?
Look at the house's recent catalogues before you consign. Are the photographs sharp, well lit, in focus and taken from several angles? Are marks, signatures and condition issues shown rather than hidden? Does the description name the maker, the pattern, the medium, the dimensions and the condition, or does it just say "vintage lot"?
Good cataloguing is where the money is made. A bidder in another time zone can't pick your item up and turn it over, so the photos and the description have to do that work. Ask who writes the descriptions and whether a specialist in that category will look at your piece. Ask, too, whether you'll get to see the listing before the sale opens.
When and how will you be paid?
Get a specific answer, in writing, to two questions: how many days after the auction closes will you be paid, and what happens if a buyer doesn't pay? Reasonable settlement windows run from two to six weeks. Vague answers like "once funds clear" are a warning sign.
Ask whether you'll receive a settlement statement showing each lot, its hammer price, the commission and any other deductions. You should be able to reconcile the check against the published results line by line. If a buyer defaults, a good house will either offer the lot again or return it to you, and should say so up front.
Is your property insured while the house has it?
Your items may sit in the house's building for weeks between drop off and sale. Ask whether they're insured during that period, for how much, and who pays if something is lost or damaged. Ask about pickup as well: if the house collects from your home, is the item covered in transit?
Most established houses carry coverage and will say so plainly. The point of asking is less about catching anyone out and more about knowing where you stand before you hand over a painting that has been in your family for eighty years.
What happens if a lot doesn't sell?
Every sale has unsold lots. Ask what the house does with them and what it costs you. Common answers include offering the lot again in a later sale at a lower estimate, holding it for a themed sale, returning it to you, or offering it in a post auction private sale. Some houses charge a fee on unsold lots, so check.
Ask about reserves at the same time. A reserve is the minimum price you'll accept. Houses differ on whether they allow reserves and how they're set. Ask whether a reserve changes the fee if the lot doesn't reach it. A house that sets sensible estimates should have a high sell through rate, so it's fair to ask what percentage of lots typically sell.
How does the process work with us?
We're a family run auction house founded in 2019, with our gallery in Edina, just off 494 and 100. We sell fine art, jewelry, sterling silver, watches, coins, antiques, collectibles and full estates, and we run every sale on five different bidding platforms. Bidding is open worldwide, and we ship to a different country nearly every sale. About 97% of our lots sell.
Here's what to expect if you consign with us:
- Send photos through sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate and you'll hear back from a specialist with a free auction estimate.
- If you decide to go ahead, you sign a one page consignment agreement that lists the commission and every other term.
- We photograph, research, catalogue and market your items, then the auction runs online for three weeks.
- Your check follows the sale with an itemized statement showing each lot.
What if you'd rather not wait for an auction?
Auction takes time. Between consigning, cataloguing, the sale itself and settlement, there's a wait before you see your money. For some sellers that's fine. For an estate that needs to close or a family that simply wants the matter done, it isn't.
For that reason we also buy sterling silver, gold jewelry and coins outright, with a same day check at the Edina gallery. Diamonds and gemstone pieces go to auction rather than being bought for cash, because competitive bidding is where they do well. Many sellers use both routes: cash for the everyday pieces, auction for the ones that deserve a wider audience.
What should you have ready before you call?
You don't need much. A few clear photos of each item, any marks or signatures, and whatever paperwork you have (receipts, old appraisals, letters, family history) will let a specialist give you a useful first opinion. If you're clearing a whole house, a walkthrough is usually easier than photographing everything, so ask whether the house will come to you.
Call any auction house you're considering and run through the questions above. The ones worth working with won't mind.
To ask us those questions, call (612) 280-1377 or submit photos at sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate. The gallery is open Monday to Friday, 10am to 4pm. You can walk in, but calling ahead means a specialist in your category will be on hand.
Have one like this?
Send a few photos and we will tell you what it is and what it should bring at auction. Estimates are free and there is no obligation. Get a free estimate. Or call (612) 280-1377.