Selling Artwork from South Dakota: Photos, Estimates and Shipping
Wondering where to sell fine art in South Dakota? Discover why consigning with SebastianCharles Auctions is the simplest path to strong prices and nationwide exposure.
You don't need to bring a painting to Minnesota to find out what it's worth. Photograph it, send the pictures through our free estimate form, and we'll tell you whether it belongs in an auction and roughly what it might bring.
That matters more in South Dakota than in most states, because the collectors who set prices for regional art mostly don't live there. A Black Hills view that a Rapid City dealer might offer $2,000 for can bring more when buyers in Denver, Santa Fe, Scottsdale and Chicago are bidding against each other. Our sales are open worldwide, we run on five different bidding platforms, and we've sold to buyers in more than 50 countries.
Which South Dakota artists do collectors look for?
Harvey Dunn leads the list. Born near Manchester, he became a major illustrator and later painted the prairie homesteads and pioneer women of his childhood. Original Dunn oils are scarce. Oscar Howe, the Yanktonai Dakota painter who taught at the University of South Dakota, is the other name with a strong national market, and his geometric, modernist work is sought by museums as well as private buyers.
Below those two, bidders look for painters of the Black Hills and the Badlands, Native American artists working today, wildlife painters with a real following, and illustrators who came out of the region. Terry Redlin of Watertown is widely known, though his market is mostly prints, covered below. If you have a signed painting by a South Dakota artist you can't find much about, send it anyway.
How can you estimate a painting you haven't seen?
The same way we'd estimate one on the easel in front of us, only from your photographs. We identify the artist and check the auction record for comparable work. We read the signature, the medium, the size and the subject. We look for condition problems in your close shots. Then we set a range that reflects what competitive bidding should produce.
For most paintings that's enough. When it isn't, we say so. A very high value piece, or one where we can't tell an oil from a printed reproduction, gets an in person look, either at our gallery in Edina or on a pickup run through South Dakota. An estimate is not an appraisal and not an offer. It's our honest expectation of what the market will do, and it's free.
What photos do you need?
Five shots, taken with a phone in daylight without flash:
- The full front, straight on, with nothing cropped off and the room lights switched off
- The signature up close, along with any date, title, dedication or inscription
- The whole back, showing labels, stamps, stretcher bars and any old auction or gallery tags
- Any damage, such as cracking, flaking, tears, foxing on paper, or a chipped frame
- A tape measure across the image so we can confirm the size, plus the frame dimensions written down
Upload them at sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate with anything you know about where the painting came from. If the paint is thick, one more shot with the light raking in from the side shows the texture and any losses that a straight photo hides.
What about prints and reproductions?
A great deal of framed art in South Dakota homes is a print, and most prints sell for modest sums. That includes many Terry Redlin editions, which turn up constantly. A signed, numbered edition on paper is worth more than an open edition on canvas board, but neither is worth a painting.
Some prints do sell well. Hand pulled etchings and lithographs by known artists, signed woodcuts, early photogravures of Western subjects and limited editions with a small run all have collectors. The way to tell a print from a painting is to look at the surface with a magnifier. A regular dot pattern means it's printed. Visible brushstrokes, ridges of paint, an irregular surface and canvas weave showing through mean it's not. If you're unsure, photograph a small area up close and we'll tell you.
How do I ship a painting from South Dakota?
Anything up to about 36 inches can go by carrier. Cover the front with glassine or clean paper, protect the corners, sandwich the painting between two sheets of rigid cardboard and tape the sandwich shut. Bubble wrap that and box it with two inches of cushioning all round. If there's glass, tape an X across it or take it out. Insure the parcel for the estimate and require a signature.
Address it to our gallery in Edina, just off 494 and 100, and call with the tracking number. For larger works or several pieces, drive them up if you can. Sioux Falls is about four hours by road, Brookings a little less. For Rapid City, the Black Hills, the western half of the state and full estates, we schedule a pickup and the painting rides insured in our own vehicle.
Should I have it cleaned or restored first?
No. A dirty painting with an old varnish sells. A painting that has been cleaned by someone who didn't know what they were doing does not, or sells for far less. The same applies to reframing and to touching up losses with craft paint. Buyers who want conservation have their own people and will price the work accordingly.
Do gather anything on paper. Exhibition records, bills of sale, a letter from the artist, an old photo of the painting on the family wall or a mention in a local newspaper all help a distant bidder trust the lot. Send copies with the painting or photograph the documents and upload them with your estimate request.
What happens after the sale?
You'll have signed a one page consignment agreement before the sale that sets out commission, any reserve, the auction date and how you're paid, with no fine print. The painting is photographed, researched, cataloged and promoted to collectors who follow that region, then offered in a three week online sale. About 97% of our lots sell.
When the auction closes, your check follows with an itemized statement showing the hammer price and what was deducted. If the painting doesn't sell, it can go into a later sale or come back to you at no charge. We ship overseas every sale, so a buyer in Germany is as ordinary to us as one in Sioux Falls.
To find out what your painting might bring, send photos through sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate or call (612) 280-1377. Our gallery in Edina is open Monday to Friday, 10am to 4pm. Walk-ins are welcome, and calling ahead means an art specialist will be on hand when you arrive.
Have one like this?
Send a few photos and we will tell you what it is and what it should bring at auction. Estimates are free and there is no obligation. Get a free estimate. Or call (612) 280-1377.