Selling Sterling Silver from Saint Paul: Flatware to Odd Pieces
If you're in Saint Paul with a chest of sterling flatware, a tea set from a grandparent's sideboard, a pair of candlesticks or a shoebox of odd silver, you have two good options: sell the metal-value pieces for cash the same day, or consign the collectible pieces to an online auction where buyers around the world bid on them. Our gallery in Edina, just off 494 and 100, does both, and it's about half an hour from most of Saint Paul. Here is how each kind of silver tends to sort out, and what to expect when you bring it in.
What happens to a flatware service?
Flatware is the silver Saint Paul families most often bring us, usually a service for 8 or 12 that was a wedding gift decades ago. The first thing we check is the pattern and the maker. A complete service in a pattern with a following, such as Gorham Chantilly, Wallace Grande Baroque, Reed & Barton Francis I, Kirk Repoussé or anything by Georg Jensen, goes to auction as a single lot with the chest and serving pieces, because collectors and dealers pay for completeness. A partial set in a common pattern, or a set with heavy wear and monograms, is usually worth more as metal, and we'll buy it for cash. Knives are priced by the handle in either case. Please don't split a service before you come in. Count the pieces and bring the whole thing.
What about tea and coffee sets?
Tea sets are where weight and design pull in different directions. A sterling service with a teapot, coffee pot, creamer, sugar bowl and tray can weigh over 100 troy ounces, which is real money as metal alone. But a set by Tiffany & Co., Gorham, Kirk, International or an English Georgian maker often brings more from a collector than from a scale, especially if the tray matches and the set is in good order. We look at the maker, the date, the condition of the handles and hinges, and whether the interior has been regilded or repaired. Weighted trays and plated trays don't add much. If the set is monogrammed, leave it alone. Removing a monogram thins the metal and hurts the value more than the initials do.
What do you do with single pieces and oddments?
Most families have a drawer of them: a baby cup, a pair of candlesticks, a compote, a few souvenir spoons, a bowl with a dent. These sort quickly. Weighted candlesticks and compotes are mostly cement and hold little silver, so they're worth less than their size suggests either way. Plain bowls, baby cups and souvenir spoons are typically cash purchases by weight. The surprises are single serving pieces in scarce patterns, since collectors hunting a specific asparagus server or ice cream fork will bid on one piece, and anything with an Arts and Crafts maker's mark, like the Kalo Shop, which sells as art rather than metal. Bring the drawer as it is. Sorting it takes us minutes and costs you nothing.
How do we decide what goes to auction and what we buy for cash?
The test is simple: would a collector pay more for this piece than a refiner would? We check the marks, pattern, weight and condition, and we know from our own sale results what a given maker brings. If the answer is yes, we quote an auction estimate. If the answer is no, we weigh the piece on a scale in front of you, confirm it's sterling, and make a written cash offer you can accept on the spot or take home. Many Saint Paul sellers leave with a same day check for the scrap and a consignment agreement for the good pieces. We'll also tell you when something you thought was sterling is plate, and when something you dismissed deserves a second look. There's no pressure in either direction.
Do you have to drive it to Edina?
Not for a first look. Upload photos of the marks and the pieces at sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate and we'll tell you what belongs where before you load the car. For a single service or a tea set, the drive is simple: take 94 or 35E to 494, then follow it west to the 100 exit. If you're clearing a whole house in Saint Paul, or the silver is one part of a larger estate with art, jewelry, coins and furniture, call us and ask about pickup. We handle full estates, and it's often easier to sort everything on site than to carry it across the river in boxes.
What does the auction side look like?
Consignment is a simple one page agreement. We photograph each lot with close-ups of the marks, research the maker and pattern, weigh it and write a description that tells buyers exactly what they're bidding on. The auction runs online for three weeks. Our sales are open worldwide, we run on five different bidding platforms, and we've sold to buyers in more than 50 countries. We ship overseas every sale, so a Saint Paul tea set can go to a collector in Tokyo without you doing any packing. About 97% of our lots sell. After the sale, your check follows with an itemized statement showing what each lot brought. A 255 piece Georg Jensen Acorn flatware service sold through our gallery for $11,500, a good example of what a name and a complete set can do.
Our gallery in Edina is open Monday to Friday, 10am to 4pm. Walk-ins are welcome, and calling ahead at (612) 280-1377 means a silver specialist will be on hand when you arrive from Saint Paul. If you'd rather start with photos, use sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate, and if you already know your silver is scrap, the details of how we buy are at sebastiancharles.com/sell-sterling-silver.
Have sterling silver like this?
We buy sterling outright and pay the same day, or sell it at auction when it will bring more. Send a few photos and we will tell you which route pays better. Sell your sterling silver. Or call (612) 280-1377.