Why Sell at Auction? How Bidding Sets the Price, and When It's the Wrong Choice
At auction, bidders set the price. Here is how estimates, reserves and competition work, with real results from our sales, and when another route fits better.
SebastianCharles Auctions
Most ways of selling start with someone naming a price. A dealer makes an offer. A shop writes a tag. A buyer on a marketplace asks what you will take. In each case one person decides what your piece is worth, and that person has a reason to keep the number low.
An auction works the other way around. Nobody names the price. Bidders set it by competing with each other in public. That is the whole case for auction, and it is also the source of its limits. Here is how it works, with real results from our own sales, including a few that did not go the seller's way.
One offer or many bidders
A dealer who buys from you has to resell at a profit, so the offer leaves room for that. Nothing is wrong with this. It is how the trade works, and it often gets you paid the same day.
At auction, those same dealers bid against each other. They also bid against collectors who plan to keep the piece and can pay closer to its full worth. You are no longer negotiating with one buyer. You are watching several buyers negotiate with each other.
An estimate is a starting point
We put an estimate on every lot. It is our best reading of what similar pieces have brought. It is not a ceiling. These results show what happens when two or more bidders want the same thing.
- An early Southwest silver and stone cuff, estimated at $50 to $100, sold for $2,300.
- A Williams No. 1 typewriter, estimated at $300 to $600, sold for $5,500.
- William Hart's painting Calm Waters, estimated at $2,000 to $4,000, sold for $12,500.
- A 1922 first English edition of James Joyce's Ulysses, estimated at $500 to $1,000, drew 45 bids and sold for $2,200.
- An ink portrait by the Nigerian modernist Uche Okeke, estimated at $1,000 to $2,000, sold for $5,000.
We did not know those prices in advance. No one did. A fixed price would have left that money with the buyer.
It cuts both ways
An auction finds the market price on the day of the sale. Sometimes the market says less than everyone hoped.
- A Tiffany and Co. platinum and diamond ring set, estimated at $12,000 to $16,000, sold for $10,000.
- An Art Deco platinum and diamond fur clip, estimated at $6,000 to $8,000, sold for $4,500.
- First and second editions of Gulliver's Travels, estimated at $10,000 to $20,000, sold for $5,000.
If a low result would hurt, ask about a reserve before you consign. A reserve is a confidential minimum agreed between you and the auction house. If bidding does not reach it, the piece does not sell. A reserve set too high protects you from a sale that would have been a good one, so set it with care.
Where the bidders come from
A local buyer can only pay what the local market supports. Our sales run online through LiveAuctioneers, Invaluable and HiBid as well as our own bidding site, and they reach bidders across the country and overseas.
That reach matters most for things with a specialized following. The Okeke portrait above came from a Minnesota collection. The strongest market for his work is in Europe, and that is where we have found buyers for it. The right bidder for your piece may not live anywhere near you.
What it costs and how long it takes
You pay a commission, taken from the hammer price. The buyer pays a separate buyer's premium on top of the hammer price. Your commission rate, the estimates and the starting bids are all written into your consignment agreement before anything goes into a sale. Read it and ask questions.
Auction is not fast. Each piece has to be examined, photographed, catalogued and shown to bidders before the sale, and the buyer has to pay before you get paid. Plan on weeks, not days.
When auction is the wrong choice
- Scrap gold and silver. Broken chains and worn plain bands sell by weight. An auction adds time and cost without adding bidders. We buy gold directly for that reason. Our post on gold buyers and auction explains how to tell scrap from pieces that deserve more.
- Everyday household contents. Furniture, kitchenware and general household goods usually do best at an estate sale or a local auction. We work with estate sale companies and local auction houses, and we compare the options in auction house, estate sale or local auction.
- You need the money this week. A direct sale is faster.
- The piece means more to you than it will to a bidder. Keep it.
What auction does best
The harder something is to price, the stronger the case for auction. That covers signed jewelry, original art, rare books, early Native American work, good sterling and anything unusual enough that no price guide exists for it. It also covers the few top pieces in an estate, where most of the value tends to sit. Our guide to estate jewelry in Minneapolis shows how that sorting works for a jewelry box.
You can browse more results in our auction highlights.
Find out which route fits your piece
Send photos and we will tell you what we think it is, what it may bring, and whether auction is the right fit. If it is not, we will say so and point you to a better option. Request an estimate here. Sebastian personally reviews every inquiry.
Have one like this?
Send a few photos and we will tell you what it is and what it should bring at auction. Estimates are free and there is no obligation. Get a free estimate. Or call (612) 280-1377.
Related articles
- When Should You Sell Silver as Scrap vs at Auction? [Complete Guide]
- Should You Sell Silver at Auction or for Scrap? [Decision Guide]
- Selling Jewelry from Iowa: How Out of State Consignment Works
- Montblanc and Other Fountain Pens Worth Money at Auction
- Selling Antiques from North Dakota: How Consigning Works