Selling Sterling Silver in Minneapolis: Cash Today or Auction

If your sterling silver is plain, worn, dented or mismatched, sell it for cash and be done in an afternoon. If it carries a good maker's name or a sought-after pattern, put it in an auction and let collectors compete for it. Most Minneapolis households that call us have a bit of both, so here is how to sort your silver at the kitchen table and how each route works once you bring it across town to our gallery in Edina.

How do you tell sterling from silverplate?

Turn each piece over and look for a mark. American sterling is stamped "sterling", "STER", "925" or ".925". English sterling carries a lion walking left, called the lion passant, with a city mark and a date letter. Continental silver is often marked "800" or "835", which is lower purity but still worth buying. Silverplate is marked "EPNS", "EP", "silverplate", "quadruple plate", "A1" or with a brand name such as Rogers or Community. A word of caution: "Rogers" appears on plate far more often than on sterling, and "Sterling Inlaid" on Holmes & Edwards flatware is plate with tiny sterling wear points. If there's no mark at all, assume plate until proven otherwise. Our free silver marks database at sebastiancharles.com/silver will help you match a maker's stamp.

Can you weigh it at home?

Yes, and it's worth doing so you know roughly what you're carrying. A kitchen scale that reads in grams is fine. Divide the total grams by 31.1 to get troy ounces, which is the unit every buyer uses. Two things skew the numbers. Knives: the handles are hollow sterling shells filled with cement or resin, with stainless blades, so a knife that weighs 80 grams might hold 15 grams of silver. Weigh knives separately and expect a buyer to price them by the handle. Weighted pieces: candlesticks, compotes, bud vases and trophies marked "weighted" or "reinforced" are mostly filler, and their silver value is small. Everything else, including forks, spoons, bowls and trays, weighs true. Write your totals down. A buyer's scale should land within a few grams of yours.

What should you bring to the gallery?

Bring all of it, sorted the way you found it. Don't polish first, since heavy polishing wears down detail and buyers can see through a fresh shine anyway. Keep pattern groups together with a rubber band or in the chest they came in. Bring:

We'll go through it together at the counter and separate the pieces that should be sold as metal from the pieces that should go to auction.

How does the cash route work?

The cash route is for silver whose value is its metal: worn flatware in common patterns, dented bowls, monogrammed serving pieces nobody in the family wants, single spoons and plain modern pieces. At our gallery in Edina, just off 494 and 100, a specialist weighs each group on a scale in front of you, confirms purity, and writes an itemized offer. If you accept, you leave with a check the same day. There's no obligation to sell, and you're welcome to take the written offer home and think about it. Details on what we buy are at sebastiancharles.com/sell-sterling-silver.

How does the auction route work?

The auction route is for pieces that collectors want as objects. Think Georg Jensen, Tiffany & Co., Gorham Martelé, Kirk repoussé, complete services in patterns like Francis I or Chantilly, and antique hollowware with clear hallmarks. You can start with a free estimate from photos at sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate, or bring the pieces in. If you consign, you sign a simple one page agreement and we handle the photography, research and cataloguing. The auction runs online for three weeks. Our sales are open worldwide, we run on five different bidding platforms, and we've sold to buyers in more than 50 countries, so a Minneapolis tea set can end up with a collector in Copenhagen. Your check follows the sale with an itemized statement. A 255 piece Georg Jensen Acorn service sold this way for $11,500.

Which route pays more?

For scrap silver, cash pays as much as an auction would, without the wait. For collectible silver, auction usually pays more, sometimes several times the metal value, because the price is set by people who want the pattern, not by the scale. The mistake to avoid is treating a good service as scrap because it seems easier. If you're unsure, ask. We sort silver every week and will tell you plainly which pile a piece belongs in, even when the answer is "sell it for cash". Many people leave with a check for the scrap and a consignment agreement for the good pieces on the same visit.

Our gallery in Edina is open Monday to Friday, 10am to 4pm, and it's a short drive from anywhere in Minneapolis. Walk-ins are welcome. Calling ahead at (612) 280-1377 means a silver specialist will be ready when you arrive, and you can send photos first at sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate if you'd like a read before you load the car.

Have sterling silver like this?

We buy sterling outright and pay the same day, or sell it at auction when it will bring more. Send a few photos and we will tell you which route pays better. Sell your sterling silver. Or call (612) 280-1377.

Related articles