Where to Sell Sterling Silver in the Twin Cities: Your Options
In the Twin Cities you can sell sterling silver to a refiner or scrap buyer, a local antiques or coin dealer, an online marketplace, or an auction house. Which one pays you the most depends on whether your silver is worth more than its weight, and on how quickly you want the money.
This guide explains how to tell what you have, what each selling route pays and costs, and which patterns and makers are worth holding out for. We run an auction house in Edina and also buy sterling for cash, so we'll say where we fit at the end.
Is it sterling or silver plate?
Start here, because plated silver has almost no metal value and most buyers won't take it. Sterling is 92.5% silver and is nearly always marked. On American pieces look for the word "sterling" or the number "925". On English pieces look for a lion passant, a small walking lion stamped into the metal. Continental silver carries numbers such as "800", "830", "835" or "900".
Plate is usually marked "EPNS", "EP", "silverplate", "A1" or "quadruple plate", or carries a company name with no purity mark at all. Weighted sterling (candlesticks, compotes, vases, trophies) is sterling on the outside with a cement filling, so only a fraction of the weight is silver. Our free marks database at sebastiancharles.com/silver will help you decode most stamps.
What does a refiner or scrap buyer pay?
A refiner pays for silver by weight, less a margin for refining and profit. That's it. The pattern, the maker, the age and the condition don't matter, because the piece is going to be melted. Payment is immediate and the transaction is simple.
This is the right choice for damaged pieces, odd single spoons, monogrammed pieces of common patterns, and weighted items with little silver in them. It is the wrong choice for anything by a known maker or in a collected pattern, because the refiner will pay weight for a piece that a collector would pay several times weight for. Before you take a full flatware service to a scrap buyer, get a second opinion on the pattern.
What does a local dealer pay?
An antiques dealer, coin shop, pawn shop or jewelry store that buys silver will usually pay a little more than a refiner for pieces they can resell, and refiner prices for the rest. A good dealer knows patterns and will pay accordingly. A dealer who quotes you one price per ounce for everything on the table is treating it as scrap.
The advantage of a dealer is speed and a face to face transaction. The disadvantage is that you're getting one buyer's offer, and that buyer needs to make a margin when they resell. Get two offers if you can, and ask each dealer to tell you which pieces they're valuing above weight and why.
Should you sell silver online yourself?
Online marketplaces let you set your own price and reach buyers everywhere. For a single pattern piece that's easy to photograph and cheap to ship, they can work well. For a large service or a tea set, the work adds up: photographing every piece, answering questions, packing heavy silver safely, insuring it, and handling returns and non payment.
Selling fees, payment processing, packaging and shipping typically take a meaningful share of the sale price, and you carry the risk if a buyer claims damage. If you have the time and a small number of pieces, it's a reasonable route. For an estate's worth of silver, most people find it isn't worth the weeks involved.
When does an auction house pay more?
When the silver is worth more than its weight and you can wait for the money. An auction puts your pieces in front of collectors who want a particular pattern or maker, and lets them bid against each other. That's how a Georg Jensen Acorn flatware service of 255 pieces sold at one of our auctions for $11,500, well above what it would have brought by weight.
The costs are the seller's commission and time. In exchange you get specialist cataloguing, photography, insurance while the silver is in our care, and a worldwide audience. We run every sale on five different bidding platforms and have sold silver to buyers in more than 50 countries. For a plain modern service in a common pattern, the commission may eat most of the premium, so ask for an honest opinion before consigning.
Which makers and patterns are worth more than weight?
Names to look for, in rough order of how much they lift value above weight:
- Georg Jensen, whose Acorn, Cactus, Pyramid and Continental patterns are collected worldwide.
- Tiffany & Co., especially 19th and early 20th century hollowware and patterns like Chrysanthemum and Audubon.
- Gorham, particularly Martelé, Chantilly, Buttercup and hand chased hollowware.
- Early American coin silver and marked colonial makers.
- English Georgian silver with clear hallmarks, and Arts and Crafts makers such as Omar Ramsden.
Other American makers such as Reed & Barton, Wallace, International, Towle and Kirk & Son have popular patterns (Francis I, Grande Baroque, Old Master, Repoussé) that trade above weight too. Complete services in original chests do better than assembled ones, and serving pieces are often worth more than place settings.
Which option should you choose?
A simple rule: if your silver is plain, damaged, monogrammed or by an unknown maker, sell it for cash and don't look back. If it's by a maker on the list above, in a collected pattern, early, or unusual in any way, get an auction estimate before you sell it by weight. If you're not sure, send photos and ask.
We buy sterling silver outright at our Edina gallery and write a check the same day, and we also sell it at auction. When you bring silver in, a specialist will tell you which pieces belong in which pile. Many families sell the everyday pieces for cash and consign the ones that deserve a wider audience.
What should you bring?
Bring everything, including pieces you think are plate. Keep sets together, because a complete service is worth more than the same pieces sold loose. Don't polish before you come. Hard polishing can wear down marks and decoration, and tarnish doesn't affect the price. Bring original chests, boxes, receipts and any family records.
If you'd rather start with photos, take one shot of each group and a close up of the marks. Send them through sebastiancharles.com/get-estimate and you'll hear back from a specialist with a free estimate.
To sell sterling silver for cash or at auction, call (612) 280-1377 or visit our gallery in Edina, just off 494 and 100, Monday to Friday, 10am to 4pm. You can walk in, though calling ahead means a silver specialist will be on hand. Details on the cash option are at sebastiancharles.com/sell-sterling-silver.
Have sterling silver like this?
We buy sterling outright and pay the same day, or sell it at auction when it will bring more. Send a few photos and we will tell you which route pays better. Sell your sterling silver. Or call (612) 280-1377.