MENU
When it comes to silver, not all that glitters is the same. Two terms that often cause confusion are plated sterling and actual sterling silver — and while they may look alike at a glance, they’re very different in terms of composition, quality, and value.
Understanding the difference between these two can help you make more informed decisions when buying, collecting, or evaluating silver items. Here’s what sets them apart.
Sterling silver refers to a metal alloy composed of 92.5% pure silver, mixed with 7.5% other metals, usually copper. This precise ratio balances purity with strength, since pure silver (99.9%) is too soft for most functional uses.
Sterling silver is often marked with “925,” “.925,” or “Sterling”, especially on American and British pieces. These stamps indicate the silver content meets the international standard.
Because it’s solid throughout, genuine sterling maintains its value over time. It can be polished, repaired, and even melted down without losing its silver content. Its weight, durability, and market value are direct reflections of its actual silver makeup.
Plated silver — sometimes referred to as silverplate or silver-plated — involves a thin outer coating of silver applied over a base metal like copper, brass, or nickel. In some cases, you’ll encounter the term “plated sterling,” which may sound like a premium version, but it still refers to a surface treatment, not solid silver.
Despite the name, plated sterling is not sterling silver. It simply mimics the appearance, using a fraction of the material. The layer of silver is usually microns thick and can wear off over time, especially on high-contact surfaces like flatware or jewelry.
Plated pieces may be marked with terms like “EPNS” (Electroplated Nickel Silver), “Silverplate,” or “SP.” If you see these rather than a 925 or Sterling stamp, it’s a clear indication that the item is plated.
To the untrained eye, both types can appear similar — shiny, well-crafted, and even antique. But while sterling silver will age and develop a patina naturally, plated silver can start to expose the base metal as it wears, often revealing yellow, pink, or gray tones beneath.
Polishing can enhance the appearance of both, but over-cleaning plated items risks removing the silver layer entirely. With sterling, polishing simply restores the surface without affecting the underlying material.
Value is one of the biggest reasons this distinction is important. Sterling silver holds intrinsic worth due to its precious metal content. Even a damaged or worn sterling item retains melt value. Plated pieces, on the other hand, generally have value based only on design, age, or brand — not the metal itself.
Durability also plays a role. Sterling silver can withstand generations of use and still be restored. Plated silver is more prone to wear and tarnish, and once the outer coating is gone, it cannot be re-polished in the same way.
The difference between plated silver and actual sterling is more than just a technicality — it affects everything from how the item wears to how it’s valued. Sterling silver is solid, long-lasting, and holds market value. Plated silver offers the look at a lower cost, but with limited longevity.
Being able to spot the difference allows you to make smarter choices, whether you’re investing, collecting, or simply trying to identify a piece in your possession.
