MENU
Inheriting sterling silver can bring a mix of emotions—sentimentality, curiosity, even confusion. Whether it’s a full set of flatware, a few serving trays, or a box of mismatched spoons, the question usually follows: what should I do with this?
Sterling silver holds both monetary and historical value, but not all silver is treated equally. Some pieces are worth preserving or selling individually, while others might be better off melted or repurposed. If you’re navigating inherited silver for the first time, this guide offers a clear breakdown of how to approach the process—without rushing into a decision.
Not everything that looks like silver is sterling. Before you assess value or consider selling, you’ll want to determine:
Look for marks like “925,” “Sterling,” or “.925” to confirm sterling content. Anything labeled “EPNS,” “Silverplate,” or “Community” is likely plated—attractive in design, perhaps, but of minimal melt or resale value.
Once you’ve identified that your items are indeed sterling, the next question is whether the silver has decorative or historical value beyond its metal content. Some sterling pieces are highly collectible, especially when they:
These kinds of pieces are often worth more as objects than as scrap. However, if what you've inherited is a pile of dented spoons or mismatched knives, the metal value might be the primary driver.
Collectors and buyers tend to gravitate toward well-preserved silver, especially when items show minimal wear and retain their original patina. Completeness matters as well—a full flatware set in a known pattern will always attract more interest than a drawer of single forks.
Even monogrammed silver, once considered a dealbreaker, has found a more accepting niche. While it can slightly reduce value, many buyers today overlook it, especially if the engraving is discreet or if the pattern is desirable enough to outweigh personalization.
Sentimental value plays a real role in inherited silver. You may not want to part with a family punch bowl, but might be less attached to 12 identical pickle forks. That’s fine. Sorting the silver into three categories—keep, sell, and scrap—can help bring clarity.
If you’re unsure, it’s worth holding onto borderline items until you can research or consult with someone who knows the market.
The instinct to clean inherited silver is understandable—but resist the urge to over-polish. Collectors often prefer original patina, especially for antique pieces. Harsh cleaning can also damage delicate surfaces or remove hallmarks.
If you’re planning to keep the silver, gentle cleaning is fine. But if there’s any chance you’ll sell, leave the surface as-is until after an evaluation. That natural aging might actually add value.
Inheriting sterling silver isn’t just about figuring out what it’s worth—it’s about understanding what you’ve received. Some pieces are deeply personal, others are surprisingly valuable, and a few may just be silver in name only.
By identifying what’s genuine, researching the makers, and balancing sentiment with practicality, you can make informed decisions about what to keep, sell, or let go. Sterling silver, after all, is one of the few heirlooms that carries both memory and material worth.
